So says this piece: Is the AI job apocalypse finally here? The evidence suggests otherwise.
In 1987, the Nobel prize winning economist Robert Solow remarked: “You can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics.” At the time, computers had been around for 40 years. Real productivity gains did emerge in the 1990s after the arrival of the internet, but they were short-lived.
John Quiggin as usual continues to be intellectually worthless.
Why do people keep recycling this nonsense from article to article? It’s wrong in three places. Quite impressive for only four sentences. Unlike this disphit, I am going to use actual data.
“Computers had been around for 40 years.” Well, sure, ENIAC came online in 1945. But it took many more years for any significant computing to be used in corporations and even longer than that for companies to change their processes to match how to work better with machines. Anyway, in 1987, 95% of offices were still all on paper and PCs had not yet made a lot of inroads. And corps had not reorganized around them — which is required for any real productivity gains.
This is common. Factories first electrified by ripping out the steam engine and sticking a dynamo in its place, leaving the antiquated multistory line-shaft layout untouched. This caused zero productivity gain in most shops. The big jumps came in the 1920s, roughly four decades after commercial electricity was widely available.
And “short-lived” my ass. This clown, he should get a job in comedy. Except nothing he says is funny, just mentally challenged. Checking the BLS, labor productivity grew about 3.3% a year from 1998 through 2005, against a 2.1% long-run average since 1947. Looking at 1995โ2004 and we still got roughly 3% a year, nearly double the pace of the two decades before. So much for “short-lived,” huh.
An explanation for the dense: A decade of near-doubled growth is fucking not short-lived. And of course productivity kept climbing after from this higher plateau. The output per hour won between 1995 and 2004 is still here, and we’re still benefitting from it every day. Lord, that I have to explain this an economist is hard to comprehend. I am beginning to think he got his degree by mail from a school in Guatemala that is actually a tamale shack.
And of course, the stats also have a huge blind spot. They can only measure what we can slap an obvious pricetag on. But we now have wonders beyond imagining. We have supercomputers in our pockets, maps that tell us where we are no matter where we are, and we can talk to friends thousands of miles away instantly by pressing a button. That’s real demonstrable wealth no matter what the GDP numbers claim.
In short, Quiggin is wrong, it’s nonsense; general-purpose technologies take time because the social side takes time. I suspect also that Quiggin’s numbers are wrong, too, but that’s a whole other issue. Just a clueless clown getting paid to write drivel.
And that’s an unproductive tale as old as time.